| Cage of God | December 1, 1971 | Jack Carter | Alan Rawsthorne |
| Cakewalk | June 12, 1951 | Ruthanna Boris | Louis Moreau Gottschalk |
| Call Me Ben | June 5, 2010 | Melissa Barak | Jay Greenberg |
| Camargo | December 19, 1872 | Marius Petipa | Ludwig Minkus |
| Cantus Firmus | September 17, 1970 | Jeanne Brabants | Johann Sebastian Bach |
| Capriccio Brillante | June 7, 1951 | George Balanchine | — |
| Capriccio Italien | May 9, 1981 | Peter Martins | — |
| Capricious Maneuvers | September 19, 2013 | Justin Peck | — |
| Caracole | February 19, 1952 | George Balanchine | — |
| Carmen | — | Roland Petit | Georges Bizet |
| Carmen Suite | 1967 | Alberto Alonso | Rodion Shchedrin, Alberto Alonso |
| Carnaval | 1992 | Ib Andersen | Robert Schumann |
| Carnaval | — | Michel Fokine | Robert Schumann |
| Carousel | November 26, 2002 | Christopher Wheeldon | Richard Rodgers |
| Catarina or La Fille du Bandit | March 3, 1846 | Jules Perrot | Cesare Pugni |
| Cave of the Heart | 1946 | Martha Graham | — |
| Celebration | May 20, 1983 | Jacques d'Amboise | — |
| Chabriana | October 6, 1979 | André Leclair | Emmanuel Chabrier, François Glorieux |
| Checkmate | June 15, 1937 | Ninette de Valois | Arthur Bliss |
| Chichester Psalms | — | Peter Martins | Leonard Bernstein |
| Chout | May 17, 1921 | — | Sergei Prokofiev |
| Chroma | November 17, 2006 | Wayne McGregor | Jack White, Joby Talbot |
| Cinderella | December 17, 1893 | Lev Ivanov, Enrico Cecchetti | Boris von Vietinghoff-Scheel |
| Cinderella | December 23, 1948 | Frederick Ashton | Sergei Prokofiev |
| Cipollino | — | Genrikh Mayorov | Karen Khachaturian |
| Circus Polka | 1942 | George Balanchine | Igor Stravinsky |
| Clari | June 19, 1820 | Louis Milon | Rodolphe Kreutzer |
| Clavigo | 1999 | Roland Petit | Gabriel Yared |
| Cleopatra | 2016 | — | Neria Goldberg |
| Cleopatra in Tarso | December 26, 1821 | Jean Aumer | — |
| Clytemnestra | April 1, 1958 | Martha Graham | Halim El-Dabh |
| Cléopâtre ballet | March 2, 1908 | Michel Fokine | — |
| Composer's Holiday | September 28, 2017 | Gianna Reisen | Lukas Foss |
| Concert Fantasy | June 6, 1981 | Jacques d'Amboise | — |
| Concertino | December 30, 1952 | George Balanchine | Jean Françaix |
| Concertino | June 16, 1982 | Jerome Robbins | Igor Stravinsky |
| Concerto | November 30, 1966 | Kenneth MacMillan | Dmitri Shostakovich |
| Concerto | March 20, 1980 | Jeanne Brabants | Gian Carlo Menotti |
| Concerto | — | Jeanne Brabants | Gian Carlo Menotti |
| Concerto Barocco | — | George Balanchine | Johann Sebastian Bach |
| Concerto di Aranjuez | September 17, 1970 | André Leclair | Joaquín Rodrigo |
| Concerto DSCH | May 29, 2008 | Alexei Ratmansky | Dmitri Shostakovich |
| Concerto voor Acht | November 9, 1974 | Charles Czarny | Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart |
| Confrontation | November 10, 1972 | André Leclair | Darius Milhaud |
| Contes Russes | — | Léonide Massine | Anatoly Lyadov |
| Coppélia | May 25, 1870 | George Balanchine, Arthur Saint-Léon | Léo Delibes |
| Coppélia | — | Attilio Labis | Léo Delibes |
| Correlazione | — | Miriam Mahdaviani | Arcangelo Corelli |
| Counter Phrases | — | Anne Teresa De Keersmaeker | Steve Reich |
| Crane song | 1944 | Nina Aleksandrovna Anisimova | Zagir Ismagilov, Lev Stepanov |
| Cristallo di Rocca | June 10, 1983 | — | Sylvano Bussotti |
| Cristoforo Colombo | 1863 | — | Paolo Giorza |
| Cydalise et le Chèvre-pied | 1915 | — | Gabriel Pierné |